The problem “Check If Two String Arrays are Equivalent” is an excellent starting point for beginners who want to get acquainted with string manipulation and array handling in Python. This problem may seem straightforward at first glance, but it also provides an opportunity to explore multiple approaches, from the naive to the more sophisticated.
Problem Statement
The problem asks us to check if two arrays of string fragments are equivalent when concatenated. Given two string arrays word1
and word2
, return true if the two arrays represent the same string, and false otherwise.
For example:
word1 = ["ab", "c"]
word2 = ["a", "bc"]
The output should be True
because “ab” + “c” is equal to “a” + “bc”.
Brute-Force Approach: Concatenation and Comparison
The most straightforward approach to solving this problem is to concatenate all the string fragments in both arrays and then compare the two resulting strings.
Python Code
def arrayStringsAreEqual(word1, word2):
str1 = ''.join(word1)
str2 = ''.join(word2)
return str1 == str2
Time Complexity
The time complexity of this approach is O(n+m), where n is the length of word1
and m is the length of word2
. This is because the join
method takes O(n) time for word1
and O(m) time for word2
.
Efficient Approach: Iterative Comparison
The brute-force approach involves creating two new strings, which might not be efficient for large arrays or strings. An alternative is to compare the arrays iteratively.
Python Code
def arrayStringsAreEqual(word1, word2):
iter1, iter2 = iter(word1), iter(word2)
frag1, frag2 = next(iter1, ''), next(iter2, '')
i, j = 0, 0
while i < len(frag1) or j < len(frag2):
if i == len(frag1):
frag1, i = next(iter1, ''), 0
if j == len(frag2):
frag2, j = next(iter2, ''), 0
if i < len(frag1) and j < len(frag2) and frag1[i] != frag2[j]:
return False
if i < len(frag1): i += 1
if j < len(frag2): j += 1
return next(iter1, None) is None and next(iter2, None) is None
Time Complexity
The time complexity remains O(n+m), but we have reduced the extra space complexity to O(1) because we no longer concatenate all the strings.
Edge Cases
Case 1: Empty Arrays
Both word1
and word2
can be empty arrays. In this case, they are equivalent.
word1 = []
word2 = []
The output should be True
.
Case 2: Arrays with Empty Strings
The arrays may contain empty strings, and they should be ignored in our comparison.
word1 = ["a", ""]
word2 = ["", "a"]
The output should be True
.
Testing Your Solution
Before submitting your solution, you should test it with various cases, including the edge cases mentioned above.
assert arrayStringsAreEqual(["ab", "c"], ["a", "bc"]) == True
assert arrayStringsAreEqual(["a", "bc"], ["ab", "c"]) == True
assert arrayStringsAreEqual(["a", "b", "c"], ["a", "bc"]) == True
assert arrayStringsAreEqual(["abc"], ["abc"]) == True
assert arrayStringsAreEqual(["abc"], ["a", "b", "c"]) == True
assert arrayStringsAreEqual([], []) == True
assert arrayStringsAreEqual(["", ""], ["", ""]) == True
assert arrayStringsAreEqual(["a", ""], ["", "a"]) == True
Conclusion
The “Check If Two String Arrays are Equivalent” problem is an excellent way to practice your skills in Python string and array manipulation. While the problem may seem simple, implementing an efficient solution can be a bit challenging. By considering various approaches and edge cases, you not only get practice but also deepen your understanding of Python’s capabilities for handling strings and arrays.